[PATCH blktests v4 0/3] Introduce nvmet target setup/cleanup helpers

Daniel Wagner posted 3 patches 2 years, 3 months ago
tests/nvme/003 |  14 ++-----
tests/nvme/004 |  21 ++--------
tests/nvme/005 |  20 +---------
tests/nvme/006 |  19 +--------
tests/nvme/007 |  14 +------
tests/nvme/008 |  21 +---------
tests/nvme/009 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/010 |  21 +---------
tests/nvme/011 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/012 |  21 +---------
tests/nvme/013 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/014 |  21 +---------
tests/nvme/015 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/018 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/019 |  21 +---------
tests/nvme/020 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/021 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/022 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/023 |  21 +---------
tests/nvme/024 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/025 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/026 |  16 +-------
tests/nvme/027 |  17 ++------
tests/nvme/028 |  17 ++------
tests/nvme/029 |  21 +---------
tests/nvme/033 |  10 ++---
tests/nvme/034 |  10 ++---
tests/nvme/035 |  10 ++---
tests/nvme/036 |  12 +++---
tests/nvme/037 |   5 +--
tests/nvme/040 |  19 +--------
tests/nvme/041 |  18 +--------
tests/nvme/042 |  17 +-------
tests/nvme/043 |  17 +-------
tests/nvme/044 |  19 ++-------
tests/nvme/045 |  18 ++-------
tests/nvme/047 |  21 +---------
tests/nvme/048 |  17 +-------
tests/nvme/rc  | 103 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++---
39 files changed, 188 insertions(+), 553 deletions(-)
[PATCH blktests v4 0/3] Introduce nvmet target setup/cleanup helpers
Posted by Daniel Wagner 2 years, 3 months ago
Updated the series according the last round of feedback and retested it. In
order to pass the 'make check' check this version depends on the upcoming revert
of 26664dff17b6 ("Do not suppress any shellcheck warnings") as discussed in the
v3 thread.

original cover letter:

Introduce helpers to setup nvmet targets. This is spin off from the refactoring
patches and the allowed_host patches [1].

Sagi suggested to record all resources allocated by nvmet_target_setup and then
later clean them up in nvmet_target_cleanup. I opted to figure out in
nvmet_target_cleanup what was allocated via the newly introdcuded _get_nvmet_ports
helper. The reason being, Hannes told me offline that he would like to add ANA
tests which will add some more ports to the subsystem. I hope with this
the code is more future proof.

BTW, while looking at this I saw that the passthru code is using the awkward
return value port when calling nvmet_passthru_target_setup. It seems some
more refactoring is in order...

[1] https://lore.kernel.org/linux-nvme/5h333eqhtw252sjw6axjewlb5bbb5ze7awekczxe3kie2lnhw6@manyer42khct/


changes

v4:
 - introduced _cleanup_blkdev helper
 - fixed --blkdev arguments passing
 - added unknown argument warning to _nvmet_target_setup argument parser
 - added rb tag

v3:
 - rebased/retested
 - use the default with _nvmet_target_setup
 - https://lore.kernel.org/linux-nvme/20230822083812.24612-1-dwagner@suse.de/

v2:
 - drop local subsys variable in passthru tests
 - do not use port as handle in passthru tests
 - free port after unregistering from subsys
 - https://lore.kernel.org/linux-nvme/20230818141537.22332-1-dwagner@suse.de/

v1:
 - https://lore.kernel.org/linux-nvme/20230818095744.24619-1-dwagner@suse.de/

Daniel Wagner (3):
  nvme/{033,034,035,036}: use default subsysnqn variable directly
  nvme/{033,034,035,036,37}: drop port handle between passthru target
    setup and cleanup
  nvme: introduce nvmet_target_{setup/cleanup} common code

 tests/nvme/003 |  14 ++-----
 tests/nvme/004 |  21 ++--------
 tests/nvme/005 |  20 +---------
 tests/nvme/006 |  19 +--------
 tests/nvme/007 |  14 +------
 tests/nvme/008 |  21 +---------
 tests/nvme/009 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/010 |  21 +---------
 tests/nvme/011 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/012 |  21 +---------
 tests/nvme/013 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/014 |  21 +---------
 tests/nvme/015 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/018 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/019 |  21 +---------
 tests/nvme/020 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/021 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/022 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/023 |  21 +---------
 tests/nvme/024 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/025 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/026 |  16 +-------
 tests/nvme/027 |  17 ++------
 tests/nvme/028 |  17 ++------
 tests/nvme/029 |  21 +---------
 tests/nvme/033 |  10 ++---
 tests/nvme/034 |  10 ++---
 tests/nvme/035 |  10 ++---
 tests/nvme/036 |  12 +++---
 tests/nvme/037 |   5 +--
 tests/nvme/040 |  19 +--------
 tests/nvme/041 |  18 +--------
 tests/nvme/042 |  17 +-------
 tests/nvme/043 |  17 +-------
 tests/nvme/044 |  19 ++-------
 tests/nvme/045 |  18 ++-------
 tests/nvme/047 |  21 +---------
 tests/nvme/048 |  17 +-------
 tests/nvme/rc  | 103 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++---
 39 files changed, 188 insertions(+), 553 deletions(-)

-- 
2.41.0
Re: [PATCH blktests v4 0/3] Introduce nvmet target setup/cleanup helpers
Posted by Shinichiro Kawasaki 2 years, 3 months ago
On Aug 30, 2023 / 11:20, Daniel Wagner wrote:
> Updated the series according the last round of feedback and retested it. In
> order to pass the 'make check' check this version depends on the upcoming revert
> of 26664dff17b6 ("Do not suppress any shellcheck warnings") as discussed in the
> v3 thread.
> 
> original cover letter:
> 
> Introduce helpers to setup nvmet targets. This is spin off from the refactoring
> patches and the allowed_host patches [1].
> 
> Sagi suggested to record all resources allocated by nvmet_target_setup and then
> later clean them up in nvmet_target_cleanup. I opted to figure out in
> nvmet_target_cleanup what was allocated via the newly introdcuded _get_nvmet_ports
> helper. The reason being, Hannes told me offline that he would like to add ANA
> tests which will add some more ports to the subsystem. I hope with this
> the code is more future proof.
> 
> BTW, while looking at this I saw that the passthru code is using the awkward
> return value port when calling nvmet_passthru_target_setup. It seems some
> more refactoring is in order...
> 
> [1] https://lore.kernel.org/linux-nvme/5h333eqhtw252sjw6axjewlb5bbb5ze7awekczxe3kie2lnhw6@manyer42khct/

I've applied the series with the fix noted for the 3rd patch. I also reverted
the commit 26664dff17b6 together. Thanks again for this clean up :)
Re: [PATCH blktests v4 0/3] Introduce nvmet target setup/cleanup helpers
Posted by Chaitanya Kulkarni 2 years, 3 months ago
>> [1] https://lore.kernel.org/linux-nvme/5h333eqhtw252sjw6axjewlb5bbb5ze7awekczxe3kie2lnhw6@manyer42khct/
> 
> I've applied the series with the fix noted for the 3rd patch. I also reverted
> the commit 26664dff17b6 together. Thanks again for this clean up :)

Seriously thanks again, it was due long time ago.

-ck